| |||
| All great truths begin as blasphemies.-- George Bernard Shaw |
Suppose that today you accept what I say, but tomorrow you reject what you accept today, will you allow me to kill you? Just because someone has accepted Islam today, is he trapped for ever in Islam? Is Islam a trap? Or is it a free religion that one can accept or reject at will? Why do muslims hold a gun to each other's head with anti-blasphemy, anti-apostasy laws? Is not Allah all powerful? If he is all powerful does he not have the power to change his mind and send you more prophets? If you say Mohammed WILL ALWAYS be the last prophet are you not usurping the power of Allah to change His mind? Doesn't Allah have the power to declare his own koran as outdated junk and not applicable anymore? Doesn't Allah have the power to cancel the prophethood of Mohammed? If he does not then he is not ALL powerful, because he is missing some powers, is he? If Allah is all powerful, why should He need you to defend Him? Doesn't Allah have the power to defend Himself? If Allah is all powerful doesn't he have the power to kill apostates Himself? Why should Allah need puny man to kill or punish on his behalf?
If a person named zullah came and said to you that an angel called gabriel appeared on his TV and said to him,
"There is no god but ballah and zullah is his last prophet"
you will ask him what is his proof, if for proof he showed you a book "zorak" that he had written himself which he said contained many scientific truths to prove its authenticity and quoted other holey books of dubious parentage that he said foretold him as a prophet, would you not laugh at him and call him a fraud?
The only reason you are believing mohammed and not zullah is because you have been brought up to believe in him, is that not so?
What proof other than the zorak (and questionable forecast quotations from other dubious holey books) does zullah have to prove that he is a prophet of ballah? What proof other than the koran does mohammed have to prove that he is a prophet of Allah?
There are many people who want to argue with me on points made in this essay. I have presented these ideas for you to think on and not to argue with you or to make you beleive in these points, you can continue with your viewpoints. I won't try to change you with argument. Argument will only increase animosity, is that not so? Faith can never be changed by argument and debate. We can argue for years and still be as convinced as ever that we are right. Faith can only be changed by lots of reading and lots of thinking. This essay is for you to read and to think about. You are welcome to reject it.
The most important point of this essay is, Do I have the right to kill you if you do not believe as I do?. Do you have the right to kill me if I do not believe as you do?. Should man be allowed to punish man in the name of god? The punishment for apostasy in Islam is death. All islamic countries condemn those who reject islam to death. Should apostasy be punished by man? Most christian majority countries including the united states have anti-blasphemy laws. Should these laws continue to exist? Will you allow me to dictate what you should believe or not believe? If not, why do you allow the state or government to dictate what you should believe or not believe?
If you believe that everyone of us should choose his or her own viewpoints without dictating to each other what the other should believe, then you believe in freedom for blasphemy and freedom for apostasy. If you believe this then we are in full agreement and all my other opinions are irrelevant to you.
This site was last modified on Sunday 08th of February 2009 07:02:07 PM Copyright © 2007 G.Shankaranarayanan. All rights reserved. |